After trying out each box in the new formula bundle I am very pleased that the flavor is still as delicious as I remember, however the reason for the non-five star review is because something in this new formula caused a reaction in my throat. Not anaphylaxis to be clear, I was okay after drinking water and leaving the rest of the cookies to my hubby (who greatly enjoyed every one of these cookies!). Also, the cookies are now smaller than I remember. The individual wrappers are cute, but not eco-friendly. If the individual wrappers were able to be recycled with Terracycle (or another company of this type) then I would be more persuaded to buy more. Still worth a try for those looking for tasty cookies!
New recipe is not bad, but these do leave an aftertaste in your mouth that previous recipe did not. I doubt infrequent consumers would be able to tell the difference. As someone who eats the PB flavor daily, the new ones have a slightly different texture and do stick in your teeth. Original formula seemed to have a creaminess that is missing in this one. These are small critiques and not deal-breakers. With that said, this recipe I feel is a downgrade from the previous recipe, which has been a staple of your product offering.
Loved them. Sweetness just right. The grains weren't so large they were hard to swallow, and nothing stuck my gums.