Reviews

Based on 2576 reviews
78%
(2016)
16%
(415)
4%
(106)
1%
(25)
1%
(14)
What Cookies?

Never received my order...hard to rate it!

Tasty!

This is a great cookie! Large size with good flavor and a nice chew.

Maxine’s has evolved to a new level. The cream sandwich cookies are amazing. You don’t have to be gluten-free or vegan to love them.

Delicious

Delicious. I already ordered more.

Like Heaven!

These Oatmeal Creme Sandwiches are sooo good for an occasional treat (they are very sweet). The cookies are soft, and the creme has a wonderful, ever so slight coconut flavor.

Really good, reminds me of creme pies from my younger days

Highly recommend

Good substitute for oatmeal pies

I have tried the oatmeal pies in the past and really liked the texture. They are a good gluten-free substitute. The chocolate is good. There’s just something that is off there. If they are substitute for the fudge rounds, they need more fudgy filling.

these are silly good

These are simply amazing. Better than the "OG". INCREDIBLE. I picked some up at Whole Foods and just wanted to give them a whirl. They seemed interesting and the ingredients were solid. HOLY WOW. They surpassed any expectation I thought I had for them. Hopped online to order more so I can make sure I get more before I go back to Whole Foods! They're THAT good!

L
Ultimate Variety Bundle
Laurie

Best treat ever, my son love them too!

Chocolate Peanut Butter Marble

So good! I bought this for my husband because he loved peanut butter in sweets. Amazing!

Favorite cookie

I love this cookie. It's hard to choose a favorite, but this is the one! So fun buying the fresh baked cookies.

Best cookie ever!

This cookie is my dream cookie! The cream, the sprinkles, the taste, all incredible! Please make this a permanent flavor of your cookies!!

D
Chocolate Chip
Demetria

Delicious!!

Great combo

Love the two cookies combined. Really tasty. Keep rebuying them.

Good but

Mine was a bit overcooked which means the cookie was tougher and had a bit of a "burned" aftertaste. A few of the other single flavors also seem to have the same level of over baking. It's still a tasty cookie. I guess the overdoneneess adds to the "home baked" charm but hoping its not a common theme for future orders.

Perfection

These are one of my favorite cookies EVER.
Soft, chewy, right amount of sweetness with a hint of salt. Yes please!

Better then the popular brand

I feel like I hit the jack pot!
I took a chance and bought these at health food gluten free place and I am so happy I did!
Delicious flavor and chew.
My new favorite, can’t wait for my order to arrive, going to try other items too. Please never skimp on the cream, this makes the cookie amazing!
Excellent company !
I will be a return customer and I will recommend your products.

S
Snickerdoodle
Susan F.
Cinnamony Snickerdoodle!

Maxine’s Heavenly hit the ball out of the park with Snickerdoodle Cookies! They taste just like the ones my Mom made when I was a child but with healthier ingredients. I REALLY love that Cinnamon is what satisfied my taste buds first. Mom’s Snickerdoodles did the same thing!

M
Gingerbread
Mary L.B.

Gingerbread

Butter or brown sugar was just slightly over- cooked in my batch. However, cookie still tasty. I like the chewy factor the butter and brown sugar give to the cookie.

Delicious 🤩would definitely recommend

Phenomenal

I absolutely love the mini birthday cake crème sandwiches. They are so delicious and just the right size. Please keep them in stock, I already ordered several times.

Excellent!

Like everybody else’s review, huge fan of the Little Debbie’s oatmeal crème pies as a kid. Came across these as an alternative with natural sweeteners

These are amazing! I’ve noticed more crème filling in the last few packs I’ve purchased and I love it!

This cookie is SO good! I loved the combination of sprinkles, frosting, and soft cookies sandwiched together. Not overly sweet and so flavorful!

Yummy

I am allergic to eggs!These vegan cookies are the bomb!

×
Order Online