Oatmeal Cream Pie

8 reviews

Limited Edition Flavor!

Our take on this childhood classic may actually be better than the original. Two oatmeal cookies brought together with cream filling—but this time there's no high fructose corn sugar involved!  

PLEASE CHOOSE QUANTITY: Our Fresh Baked cookies can be purchased individually or in packs of 4 for the most savings.

See our shipping and returns policy

Our Fresh Baked cookies stay fresh for about two weeks when left at room temperature. But simply put them in the freezer and they'll last six months or more, so don't hesitate to stock up while supplies last!

To defrost, simply take them out of the freezer and let them return to room temperature. Or keep them cold and make decadent ice cream sandwiches or more.


Gluten Free Oats*, Organic Coconut Sugar, Coconut Oil, Dates, Filling (Sustainable Palm Shortening, Organic Powdered Sugar, Organic Coconut Nectar, Tapioca Flour, Organic Prebiotic Acacia Gum, Vanilla Extract), Organic Prebiotic Acacia Gum, Flaxseed, Molasses, Cinnamon, Aluminum Free Baking Powder, Sea Salt, Baking Soda

*Glyphosate Free Oats

CONTAINS: Tree Nuts (Coconut)
Made on shared equipment with products containing Tree Nuts and Peanuts.

Customer Reviews

Based on 8 reviews
My favorite treat

I have a health condition called mast cell activation syndrome, which essentially makes my mast cells attack certain foods and cause anaphylaxis. I can tolerate these cookies, and it’s so amazing to be able to eat something that feels nostalgic, since I can no longer have the original oat meal cream pies that you find everywhere (the preservatives trigger me). Thank you Maxine’s Heavenly for providing me with a safe treat for special occasions!


These cookies are amazing, I’m so disappointed that they are so good because I’m gonna have a really hard time controlling myself. All three flavors are beyond words good.

Noreen H.

Tried these with 4 of my grandchildren, and we all loved them!


All I can say is, it was GOOD! I was surprised! It’s a shame Maxine’s isn’t selling them in a box! Then again … A box wouldn’t last me long at all!!! Great taste and texture.

Oatmeal cream pie

I loved oatmeal pie when I was younger. The oatmeal pie are good I wish the cream was more light and creamy.

Fresh Baked FAQs

How are the fresh baked cookies different from the boxed cookies?

These cookies are meant to be eaten soon after their arrival to you.They are made daily at our bakery in LA and come in flavors you won't see at the store.

What is the shelf life?

Our Fresh Baked cookies stay fresh for about two weeks when left at room temperature. Put them in the freezer and they'll last six months or more—so don't hesitate to stock up while supplies last!

To defrost, simply take them out of the freezer and let them return to room temperature. Or keep them cold and make decadent ice cream sandwiches or more.

How do I build a custom order?

If you don't want one of the pre-made bundles, you can add individual flavors to your cart. Please note that the individual flavors are sold by the cookie, so if you want more than one, update the quantity. 

How do these ship?

Our Fresh Baked cookies usually ship within 48 hours. Shipping times may vary depending on where you are as we use the most economical shipping. Shipping is included in all bundles. For custom orders, shipping is $7.99 or free if you spend more than $39.

How big are they?

Each cookie is about 3 ounces, meaning they're very big! They're perfect for gifting, parties, or just as a stock supply for everyday treating.

Are these cookies made with 100% unrefined, natural sugar?

We use coconut sugar and dates to sweeten our cookies. These are unrefined, lower glycemic sugars that don't cause a sugar spike/crash and are as close to the original plant as you can get.

Faced with the alternatives of using refined, high glycemic table sugar or alternative sugars that can cause an aftertaste and stomach upset, we felt that using these coconut sugar and dates was the most natural way to sweeten our treats.

Coconut sugar comes from the sap of a coconut palm tree and does not taste like coconut at all.

Are your cookies allergy-friendly?

Our cookies are free from many of the top allergens:

- Milk
- Eggs
- Wheat
- Soy
- Corn
- Fish/Shellfish

Many of our flavors do contain nuts and all flavors are made on shared equipment. Cross-contamination of nuts is possible. You should not eat our cookies if you have a nut allergy.

As for tree nuts, we use coconut in the form of coconut sugar and nectar. While the FDA classifies coconuts as tree nuts, most people who are allergic to tree nuts are able to eat coconut. Please note that coconut sugar and nectar is made from the sap of flower buds from the coconut palm tree, not coconuts themselves.

Learn more about allergens here.

Sweetened by Nature™

Our decadent, naturally sweetened cookies make it easy to turn your love/hate relationship with sugar into one that’s ALL LOVE. Having a sweet tooth is natural—the sugar you eat should be natural too!

In an effort to be “healthy”, many have veered towards manufactured zero calorie sugar alcohols and refined sweeteners like stevia and monk fruit to satisfy their cravings. But Mother Nature tastes pretty good all on her own, and our bodies prefer it!

So we started with Maxine’s original recipe and swapped out the unhealthy ingredients for better ones, including substituting refined, bleached white sugar with coconut sugar and dates.

Order Online